Green dollar sign in lightbulb on green background

Switching From Sole Prop to S Corp: A Simple Guide

By Gusto on December 19, 2019

This article is written by our friends at Gusto.



For many small business owners, entrepreneurship is adventurous, rewarding, and at times utterly confusing. From the outset, few people who wish to start a business spend much thought on their entity type or the tax structure of their enterprise. That’s understandable since many entrepreneurs thrive when they are coming up with ideas and putting them into action.

So for many new business owners who are eager to get things off the ground, a sole proprietorship is just fine. And it makes sense, especially if they are starting a relatively simple business where they’ll be working for themselves, and won’t be hiring any employees in the near future.

As a business grows, however, there are many reasons why a sole proprietorship may not continue to be the right entity form. If this sounds like you, you’re in luck because this post is going to cover a good solution for a new structure: the small (but mighty) corporation, commonly known as the S corp.

Business Structures, Tax Status, and S Corps—What You Need to Know

Before we dive in, we’ll point you to some useful resources on business entities and revisit tax structure just so you’re familiar with them.

Entity choice

Let’s start with entity types. There are five main entity types:

  • Sole proprietorship

  • Partnership

  • Limited liability company

  • S corporation

  • C corporation

Your entity choice has a direct impact on how you’re taxed, what degree of liability you’re exposed to, who your owners can be, and more. Each entity type has its pros and cons, so you’ll want to think carefully about your options.

Tax status

How an entity is taxed is one of the chief drivers of decisions on entity types. S corporations are often a smart choice because they are treated as pass-through entities. That means earnings from the business will “pass through” to be included on the owner(s)’ tax returns.

S corps

Subchapter S Corporations, aka S corps, is a special designation under the tax code. It provides its owners with limited liability and flow-through tax status, allowing them to avoid double taxation (more on that below).

It’s important to remember that S corps are a tax status that a business “elects” by filing Form 2553. That means the owners must first create a corporation or limited liability company, and then choose to be taxed as an S corporation by submitting the form.

How to Know When an S Corp Is Right for Your Business

There are a few key signals that should cause a sole proprietor to consider S corp status. If two of the following points are of high interest to you, an S corp will probably be the way to go.

  • You want to protect your personal assets: Many different entity types can protect owners’ personal assets, and S corps are chief among them. The bonus is, S corps have other benefits, too.

  • You want to draw a salary: If you’re a business owner who wants to take a salary as a tax-deductible expense, then an S corp is the way to go. S corp rules require owners to pay themselves reasonable compensation, and your salary helps comply with those rules. Furthermore,

  • You want flexible ownership: Interests in an S corporation can be transferred without triggering adverse tax consequences. In a partnership or LLC, the transfer of more than a 50-percent interest can trigger the termination of the entity. Also, an S corporation does not need to make adjustments to the property basis or comply with complicated accounting rules when an ownership interest is transferred.

  • You want accounting to be easy: Corporations must use the accrual method of accounting unless they are considered to be small corporations. S corporations, however, usually don’t have to use the accrual method unless they have inventory.

  • You want to avoid double taxation: Corporations are great for protecting assets, but they’re not so great for taxes. C corporations pay tax on their profits, and their shareholders pay tax on dividends or other distributions they receive. By electing S corp status, any dividends or distributions will only be taxed once: at the shareholder level.

How to convert from a Sole Prop to S Corp

If your business is operating as a sole proprietorship, and you’re a U.S. citizen or equivalent, converting to an S corporation is relatively simple.

Step 1: Establish a single-member limited liability company (LLC) (assuming that you haven’t done so). This LLC will be your legal entity structure. Forming an LLC is also relatively simple, but keep in mind that every state will have its own set of rules. In general, there are three steps to creating an LLC:

  • Get your paperwork in order. This typically consists of your: a) Articles of Organization (aka “Certification of Formation” or “Certification of Organization”). This has the basic information of your LLC: its name, member (you), and who your registered agent is; b) Operating Agreement: the document that states how the LLC is run, along with other rules, and responsibilities of the member (again, you).

  • Register with the secretary or state. You should name and register your business with the secretary of state where it will be domiciled. As a single-member LLC, you can use your Social Security Number for tax filings, or you can apply for an employer identification number (EIN).

  • Apply for licenses and permits. Depending on your business, it may be necessary to apply for licenses or permits in order to legally operate it. Check with your city and county governments to find out what requirements exist.

An attorney can help you with these items, but if your business will be pretty basic, completing them shouldn’t be too difficult.

Step 2: File Form 2553 Election by a Small Business Corporation to convert your single-member LLC to an S corp. There are four sections to a Form 2553, but most small businesses really only need to worry about one of them:

  • Part I: Election Information: This will include all pertinent information about your business. Its name, EIN, address, the date it was incorporated, when you want the Subchapter S election to be effective, your tax year, and a few other minor items. It will also ask for the details for all the shareholders, but if you’re running a sole proprietorship, that should only be you.

Filling out the required information in Part I will suffice for most businesses, but we’ll cover the other parts quickly, just in case:

  • Part II: Selection of Fiscal Year: This section only applies to businesses whose tax year will not operate on a calendar year. This can be applicable for seasonal businesses and others that have a purpose for operating on a year other than the calendar. If you think you might need an alternate tax year, talk to an accountant or other business advisor.

  • Part III: Qualified Subchapter S Trust (QSST): A QSST owns shares in an S corporation and pays its income to the trust beneficiary. If you think this might apply to you, talk to your accountant.

  • Part IV: Late Corporate Classification Election: If you file Form 2553 by the relevant deadline, then you can skip this section.

Tax advantages to S corps

There are a few tax advantages to converting to an S corporation.

  • First, because the owner of an S corp is required to pay themselves a “reasonable salary,” the business can deduct this expense for bookkeeping and tax purposes.

  • Likewise, an S corp must withhold and pay its share of FICA payroll taxes. Those are deductible expenses, too. Those expenses reduce your S corp’s overall profit, which, in turn, reduces its owner’s taxable income. Pretty great, right?

  • What’s even better is that by converting to an S corp, a business owner can avoid the 15.3% self-employment tax. Your sole prop, even if it’s organized as an LLC, can’t do that.

These are just a few of the S Corp tax advantages, for more details, check out this simple guide to S Corp Taxes.

Example

Here’s a simple example to help illustrate the tax savings

Sole Prop/LLC S Corp
Revenue $100,000 $100,000
Expenses $30,000 $35,000
Salary $0 $40,000
Payroll tax (FICA) $0 $3,060
Payroll tax (FUTA*) $0 $420*
Net income $70,000 $21,520
Your portion of payroll tax $9.890.69** $3,060
Total payroll tax paid $9.890.69 $6,540
Payroll tax savings NA $3,350.69

*Assumes FUTA wage base and rate for: $7,000 and 6% respectively.

**Includes SE tax of 15.3% and the SE tax deduction of 50%.

Whether your sole prop business is relatively new or well established, converting it to an S corp has too many benefits to ignore. It may be a slightly more complicated arrangement, but if your business is growing, it can be a good transition for the long-term.


This post is to be used for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, business, or tax advice. Each person should consult his or her own attorney, business advisor, or tax advisor with respect to matters referenced in this post. Bench assumes no liability for actions taken in reliance upon the information contained herein.

Friends don’t let friends do their own bookkeeping. Share this article.

Want a free month of bookkeeping?

Sign up for a trial of Bench. We’ll do one month of your bookkeeping and prepare a set of financial statements for you to keep. No pressure, no credit card required.

Decorative patterns