Pie charts and calculator floating on red background

What Is an S Corporation? and Should You Form One?

Some corporations are eligible for a special tax designation called “S corporation” status, which exempts them from paying corporate income taxes.

What exactly is an S corporation? How do you file to become one? And what are the advantages of becoming one?

Here’s what you need to know.

What is an S corporation?

“S corporation” stands for “Subchapter S corporation”, or sometimes “Small Business Corporation." It’s a special tax status granted by the IRS that lets corporations pass their corporate income, credits and deductions through to their shareholders.

Generally speaking, S corporations don’t pay income taxes. Instead, the company’s individual shareholders split up the income (or losses) amongst each other and report it on their own personal income tax returns.

S corporation status lets businesses avoid double taxation, which is what happens when a business is taxed at both the corporate level and business owner level. In the absence of corporate tax, the S corp “tax rate” is wherever the business owner’s personal income level falls on the tax bracket.

Keep in mind that “S corporation” is a tax designation, not a business entity type. You can’t ‘incorporate’ as an S corporation. To become one, you have to apply to the IRS.

S corps report their income to the IRS on Form 1120S.

Requirements for becoming an S corp

Step 1: become a C corp (or an LLC)

In order to elect S corporation status, your business must first be structured as a C corporation, which is just a regular corporation.

Unlike S corporation status, incorporating as a C corporation is something you have to handle through your state. For more on C corporations and what articles of incorporation you’ll need to become one, check out this guide.

Alternatively, you can elect S corp tax filing status if you’re a Limited Liability Company and you meet the IRS’ criteria for S corp status.

Step 2: make sure you qualify for S corporation status

Not all C corporations can become S corporations. In order to apply for S corporation status, your company must first satisfy the following requirements:

  1. It must be a domestic corporation—that is, based and operating in the United States.

  2. It can only have “allowable” shareholders—this means that none of your shareholders can be partnerships, other corporations, or non-U.S. citizens.

  3. It cannot have more than 100 shareholders total.

  4. It can only have one class of stock—for example, it can’t have a two-tiered common and preferred stock system.

  5. It can’t be an insurance company, bank or a domestic international sales corporation.

  6. All of the company’s shareholders must unanimously consent to S corporation status.

Step 3: file Form 2553

Once you’ve made sure that your company satisfies all of the IRS’s requirements, you must then submit Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation, signed by all of your company’s shareholders.

2553 is a four-page tax form, which looks like this:

There are four parts to Form 2553:

Part I: Election Information

This part will ask you for basic information about your company, including:

  • The name, address, date of incorporation, state of incorporation and employer identification number for your business

  • Name and contact information for a corporate officer who the IRS can contact about your application

  • Information about the tax year for which your company intends to hold S corporation status

On page two of Part I, you will also have to attach the name, address, signature, number of shares (or percentage of ownership) and social security number of each shareholder in your corporation who consents to S corporation status.

Part II: Selection of Fiscal Tax Year

This part will ask you a few questions about your business’s tax year.

Part III: Qualified Subchapter S Trust (QSST) Election Under Section 1361(d)(2)

This section applies specifically to trusts applying for S corporation status. It will ask you for the income beneficiary’s name, address, and social security number, the trust’s name and address, and its employer identification number.

Part IV: Late Corporate Classification Election Representations

This part only applies to companies that are filing their application for S corporation past the IRS deadline.

In order to qualify for S corporation status in the same year that you’re applying for it, you must file 2553 “no more than two months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect.”

So for example: if you incorporated your business on January 1st, 2019 and would like to be taxed as an S corporation in 2019, you must submit 2553 no later than March 15, 2019.

For a more detailed guide to filling out 2553, see the IRS’s instructions.

If you’re an LLC, file Form 8832

If you’re electing S corp tax filing status as an LLC, you’ll need to file Form 8832.

Further reading: Form 8832 and Changing Your LLC Tax Status

What are the advantages of becoming an S corporation?

Save on taxes

The main tax benefit of becoming an S corp is avoiding double taxation. Some business owners don’t like the idea of paying a corporation tax, then paying tax again on their individual tax returns. But to determine whether S corp status is in the best interest of you and your business, you’ll need to check with a tax expert.

S corporations only pay employment tax (Social Security and Medicare) on employee wages. All other income is paid to shareholders in the form of “distributions” that are not subject to self-employment tax, which makes S corporation status very attractive to many small businesses.

The only catch here is that if you’re a shareholder and an employee of the company, which many small business shareholders are, you must pay yourself a “reasonable salary” before paying yourself a tax-free distribution.

What exactly is a reasonable salary? The IRS has no hard and fast rules for this one. But you should try to base it on position, experience, business size and what a comparable position at another company in your industry would earn.

S corporation shareholder employees will often try to minimize their salary in order to maximize the size of their tax-free distribution. Whatever salary you decide on, be sure you’re able to justify it to the IRS if you ever get audited.

Further reading: S Corp Taxes (A Simple Guide)

Reduced tax payment if you sell

If you ever decide to sell your business, you’ll pay a lot less in taxes selling an S corporation than you will be selling a C corporation.

What are the disadvantages of S corporation status?

Strict requirements

If your company fails to meet any of the IRS’s requirements for S corporation status at any point, the IRS can revoke it immediately and tax it as a C corporation instead, which could create huge problems around tax time.

If you expect your company might violate one of the IRS’s requirements—for example, if your fast-growing company plans to expand its shareholder base beyond the 100 allowed shareholders in the near future—S corporation status might not be for you.

Closer tax scrutiny

The IRS keeps a close eye on whether the “reasonable” salaries corporate officers are paying themselves are, indeed, reasonable.

If the IRS suspects a shareholder has misreported wages in order to decrease their tax burden, they may reclassify additional corporate earnings as wages, which could increase the shareholder’s tax payment significantly.

Check in with your state

While tax advantages make the S corporation an attractive status, S corps aren’t treated equally by each state government. For instance, some states treat S corps like C corps for state tax purposes, meaning you’ll only reap the benefits at a federal level. Consult with a tax professional to make sure you’re aware of your state’s S corporation rules.

Further reading

This post is to be used for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, business, or tax advice. Each person should consult his or her own attorney, business advisor, or tax advisor with respect to matters referenced in this post. Bench assumes no liability for actions taken in reliance upon the information contained herein.

Friends don’t let friends do their own bookkeeping. Share this article.

Want a free month of bookkeeping?

Sign up for a trial of Bench. We’ll do one month of your bookkeeping and prepare a set of financial statements for you to keep. No pressure, no credit card required.

Decorative patterns